Tuesday, June 24, 2014

Chapter 4: Logical Reasoning

LOGIC
         -It is use and study of valid reasoning.
         -A proper or reasonable way of thinking about understanding something.
         -Is a branch of philosophy that concerns analysis of inference and arguments.

  • An inference involves forming a conclusion that is based on some evidence.
  • An argument consists of a conclusion and its supportive evidenced.
A theory may be developed through:
1. Deduction
2. Induction
3. Retroduction

DEDUCTION
  • "top-down" approach
  • A process of gaining knowledge.
  • It happens when a researcher works from the more general information to the more specific.
  • Considered to reserve truth.
                    Valid and Sound Deductive Argument
                                 Premise 1: All men are mortal
                                 Premise 2: Socrates is a man
                                 Conclusion: Socrates is mortal

                                 Premise 1: Every day, I leave for work in my car at eight o'clock.
                                 Premise 2: Every day, the drive to work takes 45 minutes. I arrive to work on time.
                                 Conclusion: Every day, Therefore, If I leave for work at eight o’clock today, I will be on time
  • No new information provides. It only rearranges information what is already known into a new statement or conclusion.
  • An important point to consider is that for a deductive argument to be sound, its premises should be true and whole argument should be valid.
                   Valid and Unsound Deductive Argument

                                Premise 1: The tennis ball is larger than the basketball. 
                                Premise 2: The basketball is larger than the golf ball.
                                Conclusion: Therefore the tennis ball is larger than the golf ball. 

                                Premise 1: All men are mortal.
                                Premise 2: Birds are men
                                Conclusion: Therefore, birds are mortal. 

                                 Premise 1: All cat have six legs.
                                 Premise 2: A tiger is a cat.
                                 Conclusion: Therefore, a tiger has six legs.
  • For it to be unsound, at least one of its premises should be false
                                 Premise 1: All victims of abuse have low self-esteem.
                                 Premise 2: Clowen has low self-esteem.
                                 Conclusion: Therefore Clowen is a victim of abuse.

                     Invalid and Unsound Deductive Argument
                                 Premise 1: All victims of abuse have low self-esteem.
                                 Premise 2: Clowen has a low self-esteem.
                                 Conclusion: Therefore, Clowen is a victim of abuse.

                                 Premise 1: Some teachers are musicians.
                                 Premise 2: All instructors are teachers.
                                 Conclusion: Therefore, all instructors are musicians.

Nursing Theories under Deductive Reasoning
  1. MYRA ESTRIN LEVINE- The Conservation Theory
  2. MARTHA E. ROGERS- Unitary Human Beings
  3. SISTER CALLISTA ROY- Adaptation Model
  4. DOROTHEA OREM- Self Care Deficit Theory of Nursing
  5. BETTY NEUMAN- Systems Model
  6. DOROTHY JOHNSON- Behavioral System Model

INDUCTION
  • "Bottom-up" approach.
  • A form of logical reasoning in which a generalized is induced from a number of specific, observed instances.
                        Premise 1:  Jennifer leaves for school at 7:00am and is on time.
                        Conclusion: Jennifer will always be on time if she will leaves at 7:00am.

                        Premise 1: All observed women in one area wear heels.
                        Conclusion: All women must wear heels. 

                        Premise 1: Victims of abuse who have been observed have low self esteem.
                        Conclusion: All victims of abused have low self esteem.
  • Allows conclusion to be false.
  • The conclusion states a generalization that extends beyond the observations.
  • Is viewed in terms of degrees of strength and probability that the premises lead to a given conclusion. 
Nursing Theories under Deductive Reasoning
  1. FLORENCE NIGHTINGALE- Environmental Theory
  2. AFAF IBHAHIM MELEIS- Transition Theory
  3. NOLA J. PENDER- Health Promotion Theory

RETRODUCTION
  • Abductive Reasoning
  • It is the reasoning process that starts from a set of facts and derived their most likely explanations.
Nursing Theories under Deductive Reasoning
  1. HELEN ERICKSON
  2. MARY ANN P. SWAIN        Modeling and Role-Modeling
  3. EVELYN T. TOMLIN

No comments:

Post a Comment